Melanie Amaro sings i have nothing video x factor usa 2011 first live show.
the 3rd girl for simon cowell to put through on the elimination section of the first of the live shows on x factor usa 2011 was Melanie Amaro.
Melanie Amaro sang a whitney houston song called "i have nothing", and did enough to get the judges vote and through to week 2 of the x factor usa 2011 live shows, melanie amaro seems to be a very big favourite of the x factor usa judges as well.
